John, I agree with what you have said. It is hardly worth pursuing this. I mainly posted to get a better feel for trading expectations. Like I said in my lengthy note, it became more about the principle than the $$$'s.

I would like to add that I do not feel like I am overly picky. I have received over 250 chips in trade over the past 3 months from dozens of different sources and have not voiced concern over a single one of them (even though they were in a wide variety of conditions). I have already planned to upgrade some of them.

As far as putting these two chips in my traders, I would feel guilty sending these (and a few of the others) out to anyone. I guess if I advertise them as very dirty with nicks and wear on them I would not feel guilty, but then again, who would be lining up to get them?

Thank all of you for your replies and good advice...I am learning.