Given that Pavlik has been in the middle of the majority of the "bickering" that has happened over quite a few years, it sure looks like he is the actual reason you didn't renew.

He has lied about the club's rules. He has lied about and personally attacked members of the BOD and other club members both here and on the club BB. He has slandered members of the BOD to other club members while at the annual convention. To let all of what he has done to stand without comment or defense would be unacceptable. It is not what I would call "bickering".