Without going into the details, at least for the moment, here is the question.

A PRFEFACE FIRST!

The chips are the same issue. The wear on the one on the right and some of the dirt, etc., unremoveable, is much more signifigant then the one on the left.

BUT...the one on the left has a signifigant RIM NICK missing on the edge, stretching from about 2:00 to about 4:00, other than that it is in sinifigantly better shape, with less wear, you still see some of the finish texture, etc. The RIM NICK chip is the ONLY flaw on that chip and does not go through to the other side by any means!

Which chip would your rather have?.