"The chips in question do not seem to meet the definition anymore than a set of KISS chips placed in a case by the Palms and sold as a set."

The case was a common 59¢ CD case, with a couple $1,000's in artwork tucked into the pockets. No chips were placed in them by the Palms. Collectors placed the chips in the case which was given to them at no cost.

Just thought I would explain that since I know you lead a sheltered life when it comes to NV chips ever since the dreaded grounhog chip back in 1998.