>>>I don't have any idea why you think it matters whether the grade is a grade due to "condition" or "authenticity"

I simply don't accept that "authenticity" can be graded.

>>>The SlabFree club (formerly the Slabfree chapter) was not the producer of the Pledge or List

Interesting. Who came up with it?

>>>There are and were members of the Chapter/Club who did not support slabbing but objected to the Pledge

I'm right there with them.