I don't have any idea why you think it matters whether the grade is a grade due to "condition" or "authenticity"

But moving to a more important matter, for those who weren't around the last time:

"The Club" has nothing to do with "The Pledge" or "the List"

The SlabFree club (formerly the Slabfree chapter) was not the producer of the Pledge or List and did not make the Pledge a part of membership. There are and were members of the Chapter/Club who did not support slabbing but objected to the Pledge. There were people who signed onto the Pledge who were not Chapter members.

Lastly, some info about slabbers may no longer be up to date. Mark Scott of Sahara Coins announced on this board that he would no longer sell slabbed chips. At that point (absent evidence to the contrary) I believe his name should have been removed from that list of people selling slabs. I know that some members disagree with this, but they are wrong.