I disagree John. If this was an official request by the International ... that was repeatedly ignored as Robert tells me it was in his emails to me.... then the International should have taken official action against the Chapter for non-compliance. It's not up to Robert Eisenstadt to be the bag man for the CC & GTCC. He had no authorization to make such a request from the Chapter. If I were a Chapter member who requested that my information be held in confidence, I would feel betrayed if that unathorized information was given to another Chapter member.