The Chip Board
Custom Search
   


The Chip Board Archive 02

The published rules do not prohibit ...

... such bids, Peter. Furthermore, as Jim Kruse mentioned in his post, it would be impossible for him to tell if they were occurring. And, the auction format, which permits seller "protection bids" [funny how David Whalen was blasted for saying he used "protection bids" on eBay], and does not allow for either reserves or minimum bids, certainly encourages third party shill bidding to protect a seller's investment.

In any event, seems to me that if the rules don't prohibit shill bidding, then it's permissible. At least, I wouldn't want to be the lawyer who has to convince a judge or jury that it's not allowed when the rules don't prohibit it.

----- jim o\-S

Messages In This Thread

Auction Shill Bidding -- THE POINT ...
Re: Auction Shill Bidding -- THE POINT ...
The published rules do not prohibit ...
Re: The published rules do not prohibit ...
Re: The published rules do not prohibit ...
I'm still not convinced that ...
Re: I'm still not convinced that ...
Damn... There goes my free beer (NT)
Re: Damn... There goes ...
Re: Auction Shill Bidding -- THE POINT ...
Re: Auction Shill Bidding -- THE POINT ...
Re: Auction Shill Bidding -- THE POINT ...
Re: Auction Shill Bidding -- THE POINT ...
Re: Auction Shill Bidding -- THE POINT ...
Re: Auction Shill Bidding -- THE POINT ...
Re: Auction Shill Bidding -- THE POINT ...
Archie, the club auction may be ...
Re: President Sarles; the club auction may be ...
Re: President Sarles; the club auction may be ...
Re: President Sarles; the club auction may be ...
Archie, this post warrants ...
Further response ...
Re: Further response ...
See my response to Jim Kruse ...
Re: See my response to Jim Kruse ...
Precisely correct on this point ...
Re: Four things ...
Re: Auction Shill Bidding -- THE POINT ...
Re: Auction Shill Bidding -- THE POINT ...
Wasn't really trying to bring about ...
See marv Weaver's excellent post ...
Re: Auction Shill Bidding -- THE POINT ...
You have made some excellent POINTS ...
Re: Auction Shill Bidding -- THE POINT ...

Copyright 2022 David Spragg