The Chip Board
View Thread Reply Return to Index Previous Next
Hmmm
By:Michael Siskin R-7387 CCCC-5 (68.161.89.64)
Date: 4/24/08 8:57 am
In Response To: Re: I disagree (Bob Orme R-3576 SlabFree CH-20 Colorado)

I don't really want to get involved in this discussion, but I feel compelled to correct something I see in your post. You wrote:

the government should have no right to tell the owner(s) what legal activities can take place on their private property

Who do you think dictates what is a legal activity? If a law is passed prohbiting smoking in buildings open to the public, such as a casino, then smoking in such a building is NOT a legal activity. Every activity, murder included, is legal until the government enacts a law declaring that it is not. Smoking in certain buildings is no different. Therefore, your argument becomes irrelevant, or simply incorrect. Since it is not a "legal activit[y]," then your statement is irrelevant to the discussion. Since the New Jersey State government absolutely has the power (and "right") to pass criminal laws, then your statement is just plain false. It is possible that there is a "takings" issue, but that is merely a matter of compensation, and not an issue of whether the government has the right. Where, as here, there is a health matter at issue, and the public is invited onto the properties in question, the States clearly have the right to regulate private behavior.

Michael Siskin

Password:

Messages In This Thread

NCR New smoking law in Atlantic City...
Todd Siegel R-7264 (96.239.236.173) -- 4/23/08 5:48 pm
Re: NCR New smoking law in Atlantic City...
Peter M. CC&GTCC R-3182 (4.236.207.66) -- 4/23/08 6:27 pm
Re: NCR New smoking law in Atlantic City...
Robert Touts R-4583 ( N.J.) (69.115.114.83) -- 4/23/08 8:23 pm
4581 to 4583......
Bill Thompson R-4581 (69.155.44.105) -- 4/23/08 8:40 pm
Re: NCR New smoking law in Atlantic City...
calvin polansky R-3455 (65.54.97.152) -- 4/23/08 8:28 pm
I think it's great! vbg YEA
James McFadden [ UT ] LM 5036-197 (71.219.0.102) -- 4/23/08 8:32 pm
Re: I think it's great! vbg YEA
calvin polansky R-3455 (65.54.97.152) -- 4/23/08 8:36 pm
We have strict anto smoking laws in BC
Rick Armstrong #R-7614 (24.68.49.80) -- 4/23/08 11:33 pm
Nah, it's just a matter of time
Bill Thompson R-4581 (69.155.44.105) -- 4/23/08 8:43 pm
Re: NCR New smoking law in Atlantic City...
Bob Orme R-3576 SlabFree CH-20 Colorado (70.215.163.61) -- 4/23/08 8:48 pm
I have to agree with you on that one Bob.
Doug "Cigarman" Smith LM-3209-147 (TX) (205.188.117.195) -- 4/23/08 9:08 pm
I disagree
James McFadden [ UT ] LM 5036-197 (71.219.0.102) -- 4/23/08 9:23 pm
Your missing the point here James.
Doug "Cigarman" Smith LM-3209-147 (TX) (205.188.117.195) -- 4/23/08 9:29 pm
I respect your opinion Doug and
James McFadden [ UT ] LM 5036-197 (71.219.0.102) -- 4/23/08 9:46 pm
Thanks James and I do understand where your
Doug "Cigarman" Smith LM-3209-147 (TX) (205.188.117.195) -- 4/23/08 9:59 pm
Re: I disagree
Bob Orme R-3576 SlabFree CH-20 Colorado (70.209.96.86) -- 4/24/08 1:43 am
Typical smoker's response
Bill Thompson R-4581 (71.158.216.213) -- 4/24/08 7:12 am
Typical smoker's response NOT!
Bob Orme R-3576 SlabFree CH-20 Colorado (70.212.177.213) -- 4/25/08 1:22 am
Hmmm
Michael Siskin R-7387 CCCC-5 (68.161.89.64) -- 4/24/08 8:57 am
Makes me want a cig!! Viva Las Vegas vbg
Craig Duke (LV) R-7533 (76.4.234.181) -- 4/23/08 9:31 pm
Don't worry. Thursday is cigar night at Kramers'.
Rich Hanover www.OldPokerChips.com LM-4191-28 (38.117.128.14) -- 4/24/08 7:06 am
rofl AMEN rofl
George Buckner R-5849 (74.128.107.105) -- 4/23/08 9:52 pm
Re: NCR New smoking law in Atlantic City...
John Chopek R-6386 NJ (72.90.1.119) -- 4/24/08 2:16 pm
Great News!!!
Scotto Harmon (R-4940) (67.80.78.42) -- 4/23/08 8:43 pm
Great news.
Justin F. CC+GTCC member R-6672 (74.74.109.119) -- 4/23/08 8:55 pm
Guess the Asian people will...
Chris Sevick R-6355 (64.252.162.127) -- 4/23/08 9:20 pm
A dip and the crowd will return
James McFadden [ UT ] LM 5036-197 (71.219.0.102) -- 4/23/08 9:28 pm
Re: Guess ALL casino players will...
Archie Black HLM-001 (67.81.25.96) -- 4/24/08 9:54 am
Us humans conform real easy ...
John Benedict [FL] R-388 (209.240.206.214) -- 4/23/08 10:49 pm
Just look at all of the smoke-free poker rooms
Michael Siskin R-7387 CCCC-5 (68.161.89.64) -- 4/24/08 9:04 am
Re: poker players lining up to play??
Gene Trimble LM 2192-170 (70.173.149.96) -- 4/24/08 9:42 am
Re: poker players lining up to play??
Archie Black HLM-001 (67.81.25.96) -- 4/24/08 9:59 am
Re: poker players lining up to play??
Gene Trimble LM 2192-170 (70.173.149.96) -- 4/24/08 10:22 am
Don't want to argue with you either Gene ...
Archie Black HLM-001 (67.81.25.96) -- 4/24/08 10:26 am
In fact, the Borgota EXPANDED
Archie Black HLM-001 (67.81.25.96) -- 4/24/08 10:28 am
Re: In fact, the Borgota EXPANDED
Gene Trimble LM 2192-170 (70.173.149.96) -- 4/24/08 5:57 pm
You don't think the internet gambling
Michael Siskin R-7387 CCCC-5 (68.161.89.64) -- 4/24/08 10:07 am
Re: Us humans conform real easy ...
Archie Black HLM-001 (67.81.25.96) -- 4/24/08 9:42 am
Re: Us humans conform real easy ...
John Benedict [FL] R-388 (209.240.206.194) -- 4/24/08 9:49 am
The Hustler Casino...
Jay Sands LM-4390-60 (64.14.248.62) -- 4/24/08 11:58 am
And although LA has done a lot to...
Jim Follis - LM 3872-53 (199.46.245.230) -- 4/24/08 1:41 pm
I kind of doubt that...
Jay Sands LM-4390-60 (64.14.248.62) -- 4/24/08 1:45 pm
Tongue-in-cheek Jay. But you are right...
Jim Follis - LM 3872-53 (199.46.245.230) -- 4/24/08 2:05 pm
Use chewing tobbacco, thatll show em vbg
von mckenzie R-7134 (FL) (71.197.35.240) -- 4/24/08 7:16 am
Reply
Your Name:
Your E-Mail Address:
Subject:
Message:
To include a link to another page with your message,
provide both the URL and the title of the page:
Optional Link URL:
Optional Link Title:
To include an image (picture) with your message,
provide the URL of the image file:
Optional Image URL:
To have the option of deleting your post later,
provide a password (CASE SENSITIVE!):
Password:
Email me when a reply is posted
 


(C) Greg C. Susong