Thanks for your response Eric.

Its sounds like your first visit may have been from the 1981-1995 period when Jo Bell Findlay owned the card room, and called it "Jo Bell's". It sounds like your second visit was to "Mike's Card Casino" after they moved down the street around 2010.

To solve this mystery we need just one card player who stopped by between 1995 and 2002, to have kept a chip. I have my fingers crossed that he or she will see this post.