"I won 7 auctions....make that 5, and got 2 2nd chance offers from him, which I took, so he must have multiples on chips...."

I know he has multiple chips. I once won an auction about 10 years ago and didn't get the chip he showed in the auction. I guess he didn't get the price he hoped to and I got a chip of lesser quality than pictured. Hope you get what you saw.
Barry