Everyone is entitled to their opinion. It is my personal opinion that Mr. Garrad was duped by someone else who has an axe to grind, who didn't have the guts to address the question himself, but instead relied on Mr. Garrad to do his dirty work. Mr. Garrad compounded the problem by misrepresenting himself to be a current club member (which according to the club records, he evidently is not) which then diminished his credibility even further.