We were probably looking at a Steakhouse as a priority although most types of food are an option other than the Seafood. Most Steakhouses seem to do Seafood starters for some strange reason. So somewhere with a varied starter menu is a must.
We will be based in Times Square but a short taxi ride is not a problem. Our budget would be $200 for the two of us for this special occassion and so pretty much anywhere price wise.

Thanks