EXACTLY! Just dirty with some scratches, I think. I'll take my magnifying lens and check closer. I'll have to see if they're in a better selling mood, or is the $15 offer for any condition? Will you pay postage also? I'm almost sure these people don't have a Seymor book, so I think they're just guessing, but you never know. She was inclined to hold to her price because it was an advertising/clay chip cross-collectible.