"and what he does is NOT defrauding other collectors."

I'd have to say that's true, in that what David does is clearly known by his customers. What his customers might do afterward is where there is a potential for fraud, and that's where there is a need for disclosure whenever such items exchange hands.

I met David for the first time last weekend and asked him quite a few questions. He was an open book, answered all of my questions with what I believe to be complete honesty. I truly did enjoy talking to him.

For what its worth, I'm having a couple metal (one brass, one pewter) core chips "customized" for my own collection, and I'm really looking forward to seeing the finished job.

Bob