The Chip Board
Custom Search
   


The Chip Board Archive 12

Tom, I respectfully disagree with you...
In Response To: Because I got one for $50 ()

I don't know you, but I do know some of the other people who've offered you the chips and commented on your threads.

That being said, I would like to address a comment you made when referring to "all of you"...

"Your over all opinions and intent to take advantage of someone, is noted."

You appear to arrive at this conclusion based on unsound reasoning and I'd like to examine what really happened...

1. You repeated beg over a period of days for someone to sell you The Chip.
2. No one is interested in selling their chip. In fact several people tell you they wouldn't sell at any price.
3. You point out that "everything has a price", and say you'll pay any amount for The Chip.
4. You're proved right - a few of the members ARE willing to sell at a price that represents the value of the chip to them. (ranging from $100 - $250)
5. You then refuse to accept any of the offers and accuse them of price gouging.
6. Several others get involved in thread trying to understand what your motivation is (begging for a chip at any price and then refusing to buy those offered to you) and why you won't clearly explain yourself.
7. You summarily accuse "all of us" of conspiring to take advantage of you.

Doug and the other two weren't trying to take advantage of you. They had something that they didn't want to part with, but as you pointed out - everything has a price. You can't accuse them of trying to take advantage of you because you asked them to name their price (the value of the chip to them) and they did so.

As an analogy - my wife has a poodle(she treats them like children), and sometimes I think she loves them more than me grin. The FMV of a poodle is probably $300 - $500. If you tried to buy one from her for that amount (or even 10 times that amount), she'd refuse to sell. However, if you offered her a million dollars for one - I think you'd be the proud owner of a new poodle. That doesn't mean she was trying to take advantage of you.

Also, it still is not clear what you were trying to accomplish the past few days. Were you...

a) actually trying to buy the chip?
b) trying to determine a Fair Market Value for the chip?
c) trying to artificially inflate the FMV of the chip?

I think most of us assumed a) at first. But to be honest, it appeared to me (as an unbiased watcher) that you were trying to accomplish c) or possibly b) after you were refusing to be forthcoming earlier today.

Bottom Line - I think that's why you received a lot of antagonistic responses today. You appeared to be trying to be sneaky about something (and trying to artificially inflate a FMV is a serious offense in our hobby).

I hope you understand now how this appeared to most of us, and we weren't conspiring to take advantage of you.

Messages In This Thread

Come ON! Someone has to have this chip to sell.
I always thought I would never sell mine...... But
Don't you think the chip is worth $250?
You want to send my a Paypal Payment, or would you
I havent seen a Paypal yet. Is it on the way????
Tom, I thought you had an offer...
Was the offer from you?
Was this offer not sincere?...
I don't think so!
You might be on to something!
Re: Was this offer not sincere?...
Sounds like smoke in the wind
dICK do you have 1 to sell?
Tom, in your post above you said
Value is what one will pay.
Tom, it has now become crystal clear to me that
Please answer my questions!
Reasonable answer, was that a reasonable price?
Personally, I believe ....
Do you have one for sale?
Re: Reasonable answer, was that a reasonable price
Cool Macao collection, Doug! grin
Thanks Mark, I like them too grin
Tom, it is now clear to me that you have no
I do, I do,,,,,,,,,give me a honest price.
Re: I do, I do,,,,,,,,,give me a honest price.
Thanks for the support Chris
I think.....
Post you name!
Re: Come ON! Someone has to have this chip to sell
Re: I Withdraw My Offer to Sell You This Chip
Re: I Withdraw My Offer to Sell You This Chip
Because I got one for $50
Tom, I respectfully disagree with you...
I was trying to...................................
Thats right Tom, we are a club trying to screw
Doug was one of the 1st collectors I ever met...
Hey, Doug, how dare you ...
You were trying to hide.....
What is POS hustler mean!
It Doesn't stand for "Point Of Sale" rofl
Thanks Will, I know others feel the same way.
Re: Thanks Will, I know others feel the same way.
All you have is time!
Re: Tom, I respectfully disagree with you...
Good point, Paul!
Re: I doubt that Tom Post who sold it to you
Why? You don't think one of you could be honest?
Re: Why? You don't think one of you could be hones
Nnnnnnnnnnnnnnoooooooooooooorrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrmmmmmm

Copyright 2022 David Spragg