"Never had this problem"

How would you know??

No, the email never came back, I don't know what they did with it.

Anyway, I'll just send the message here so that you'll get it. Both you and Scott were claiming the knockout for me in Tourney #7. I requested a hand history and sent it to Todd to decide who should get the chip. Here is the response.

From: "D. Todd Desnoyers"
To: "Greg Susong"
Subject: Re: I need your help
Date: Tue, 19 Oct 2004 15:01:31 -0500
X-Mailer: Microsoft Outlook Express 6.00.2800.1437

Greg,

After looking over the hand history, Scott will win the chip. Greg had
more chips at the start of the hand but this is irrelevant since he won the
low side of the pot. The HIGH hand in a knockout situation, in this case a
full house, gets credit for the knockout.

High-Low split is a different animal isn't it!! If you need anymore help
or have any questions let me know.

Todd

----- Original Message -----
From: "Greg Susong"
To: "Todd Desnoyers"
Sent: Tuesday, October 19, 2004 9:34 AM
Subject: I need your help

> Greg & Scott both say I owe them a chip for knocking me out of the
> tournament last week. Here are the details of that hand. Who do I owe
the
> chip to?
>
> PokerStars Game #768345103: Tournament #2969691, 7
> Card Stud Hi/Lo Limit -
> Level VI (150/300) - 2004/10/13 - 23:25:26 (ET)
> Table '2969691 2'
> Seat 1: chipchef (2478 in chips)
> Seat 2: kc_chipper (4631 in chips)
> Seat 3: gsusong (241 in chips)
> Seat 4: Scotski (3503 in chips)
> Seat 5: Gxpress (3806 in chips)
> Seat 8: Casinoplr (1442 in chips)
> chipchef: posts the ante 25
> kc_chipper: posts the ante 25
> gsusong: posts the ante 25
> Scotski: posts the ante 25
> Gxpress: posts the ante 25
> Casinoplr: posts the ante 25
> *** 3rd STREET ***
> Dealt to chipchef [9c]
> Dealt to kc_chipper [2c]
> Dealt to gsusong [3d Kd 2d]
> Dealt to Scotski [7s]
> Dealt to Gxpress [Ac]
> Dealt to Casinoplr [Jh]
> kc_chipper: brings-in low 50
> gsusong: calls 50
> Scotski: calls 50
> Gxpress: calls 50
> Casinoplr: folds
> chipchef: folds
> *** 4th STREET ***
> Dealt to kc_chipper [2c] [5s]
> Dealt to gsusong [3d Kd 2d] [Jd]
> Dealt to Scotski [7s] [6s]
> Dealt to Gxpress [Ac] [6c]
> Gxpress: checks
> kc_chipper: checks
> gsusong: bets 150
> Scotski: calls 150
> Gxpress: calls 150
> kc_chipper: calls 150
> *** 5th STREET ***
> Dealt to kc_chipper [2c 5s] [Qs]
> Dealt to gsusong [3d Kd 2d Jd] [9s]
> Dealt to Scotski [7s 6s] [5d]
> Dealt to Gxpress [Ac 6c] [8s]
> Gxpress: checks
> kc_chipper: checks
> gsusong: bets 16 and is all-in
> Scotski: calls 16
> Gxpress: calls 16
> kc_chipper: calls 16
> *** 6th STREET ***
> Dealt to kc_chipper [2c 5s Qs] [Js]
> Dealt to gsusong [3d Kd 2d Jd 9s] [4d]
> Dealt to Scotski [7s 6s 5d] [Td]
> Dealt to Gxpress [Ac 6c 8s] [4h]
> Gxpress: checks
> kc_chipper: checks
> Scotski: bets 300
> Gxpress: calls 300
> kc_chipper: folds
> *** RIVER ***
> Dealt to gsusong [3d Kd 2d Jd 9s 4d] [9h]
> Gxpress: checks
> Scotski: bets 300
> Gxpress: calls 300
> *** SHOW DOWN ***
> Scotski: shows [Ts 7h 7s 6s 5d Td Th] (HI: a full house, Tens full of
Sevens)
> Gxpress: shows [Qc Ah Ac 6c 8s 4h 2s] (HI: a pair of Aces; LO: 8,6,4,2,A)
> Scotski collected 600 from side pot
> Gxpress collected 600 from side pot
> gsusong: mucks hand
> Gxpress said, "nh"
> Scotski collected 507 from main pot
> Gxpress collected 507 from main pot
> *** SUMMARY ***
> Total pot 2214 Main pot 1014. Side pot 1200. | Rake 0
> Seat 1: chipchef folded on the 3rd Street (didn't bet)
> Seat 2: kc_chipper folded on the 6th Street
> Seat 3: gsusong mucked [3d Kd 2d Jd 9s 4d 9h] - HI: a flush, King high
> Seat 4: Scotski showed [Ts 7h 7s 6s 5d Td Th] and won (1107) with HI: a
> full house, Tens full of Sevens
> Seat 5: Gxpress showed [Qc Ah Ac 6c 8s 4h 2s] and won (1107) with HI: a
> pair of Aces; LO: 8,6,4,2,A
> Seat 8: Casinoplr folded on the 3rd Street (didn't bet)
>