Well, Chuck's question didn't last very long. Looks like the first guess was correct. I, being a fan of baseball and baseball trivia, would like to pick up the ball with a new question that might last a little longer and attract a few more guesses.

So, here it is:

What player hit a home run in his first at-bat in the major leagues, played 21 more years and never hit another home run?

If you guess this one too quick, I'm gonna have to post some more...