How did everyone else do with the jeweler selling Thunderbird chips? I'm sure there was a post... but I must have stayed in bed that day

This is his discription:
HERE WE HAVE IS ALL ORIGINAL (THE REAL THING) THE THUNDERBIRD CASINO THAT WAS IN LAS VEGAS, HERE WE HAVE IS A $5 CHIP, THESE ARE THE SAME CASINO CHIPS THAT WERE USED IN THE TABLE GAMES(THIS IS NOT A REPRODUCTION THESE ARE THE REAL CHIPS GUARANTEED 1000%)THESE CHIPS ARE GETTING HARDER AND MORE DIFFICULT TO FIND IN THIS CONDITION, THE EDGES OF THESE CHIPS ARE NOT ROUNDED THEY HAVE A VERY GOOD EDGE, THESE ARE BEING SOLD AS ONE $5 CHIP PER AUCTION, THIS WILL ADD TO YOUR COLLECTION, PLEASE ANY QUESTIONS PLEASE LET ME KNOW THANKS JOE

This is the chip I received today (@ $2.50 shipping...)

Now - first issue is "sharp edges"... call me an idiot... but I have seen sharper edges on flat tires
The top arrow is a good sized "chip" and the center arrow doesn't show it, but there is a dent... like someone jabbed it with a metal punch.
The reverse has a cig burn...
Needless to say, I am disappointed.

He says I can return it... (at my expense) - which means I get socked with a total of $3.50 shipping for a misleading auction. (and I had better use Delivery Confirmation since he won't refund my $$ without the chip... add another $.50.

All I wanted was a chip SIMILAR to those shown in the auction!! Not one that was "perfect"... but a nice edge would have been great! No holes or missing parts... I dunno

So OK you guys - set me straight... am I just being a whiner?