Of Posada is not Yogi, and NOBODY is Joe D, but Jeter is probably a better all around player than Scooter was (they have different skills so it is hard to compare).

As for smirks or temper tantrums I have no idea what you are talking about. With the exception of Paul O'Neil whose anger is usually directed at himslef the Yankees are one of the calmest teams in baseball. Perhaps you prefer the old time drunkin brawling of Martin and Mantle.