"My guess is you've lost some potential future bidders on your "real chips." I know of at least one."

Make that two.

I don't know how someone can, with a straight face, sell a well know fantasy chip for $23 on eBay without feeling some guilt or pangs of integrity lost. I hope the buyer doesn't think we are all out to screw people by selling them fake chips. Nice way to make the club and dealers look like complete jerks.