Charles wrote...

""""""""How exposed would I be if I just report incidents, that are backed by documentation. I would never say if someone was a good guy or a bad guy, just that they were involved in a certain situation and that these are the facts of the situation. I could give both parties the opportunity to verify the facts before they are published. """""

There are already PROFESSIONAL people who do what you are proposing. Including eBay Safe Harbor, the U.S. Postal Inspectors, and a number of internet sites.

Charles, you must have a LOT more spare time than I do. :^)

Steve